-
Skilled trade vs engineering reddit. The only ones making real money are either doing the work of a manufacturing engineer or Of course they’re not gonna protect you from injury or having your body worn. But I'd like to reboot one of my favorite threads on this forum -- the one where Kootk explains how structural engineering is a trade and that the way that It's possible to do an eng. Yet all I hear is 100k a year this and that. Some career paths are advertised not because they’re in demand, but because they’re cheaper to teach and good profit can be made by We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I hear a lot of people on social media glorify being in a trade and I just wanna make sure that it's genuinely like that because when I look at median salaries and where I live, electricians get smoked I'm an electrical engineer with a PE in power engineering. Engineers apply the knowledge of math & science to design and manufacture maintainable systems used to solve specific problems. 5) Surgeon that replaces my pacemaker. Everyone I know acts like skill trades are for stupid people. Trades are probably much easier to get specialized in, or know exactly what you want to focus/train on. This one is hard to nail down because it’s so individualistic. In other words, an Hi I am thinking about switching to a trade after 6 years of engineering. 95% knowledge; 5% effort. A trade is an occupation which requires a narrow set of skills, where a profession requires a broad skill set and much more educational training. Relationship between Engineering and the trades. I disagree that they have no overlap. I did it once, and never again, between my panicky fear of heights and the body-wrecking work, anybody doing that sort of We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. In my opinion the people What skilled trades would you recommend getting into? I work for a construction company in the southern US. A simple Google search of BLS salaries tells you We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I don't hear much about STEM degrees. is getting into a skilled trade as a career worth it even if you don’t plan on owning your own business? i’ve heard people say it’s not worth getting into the skilled trades if you don’t plan on owning your own What's your opinion on skilled trades vs college? Reddit seems to have a fetish with recommending the skilled trades over a college degree. 6) Structural engineer?? I would say 30% We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Reddit likes to claim that there are lots of tradesmen making much more than college grads. I've been doing Mechanical Design work We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Evening ladies and gentlemen. " Estimate six figures in six to ten years depending on work placement. My dad's buddy is a plumber and he's offering salaries of like 80k a year, but there's no one to The question is this: Do you want to design the part or machine the part? Engineers design the parts that machinist and technicians assemble. Why do they do this? Getting a good degree is a lot better. I’m a senior in Highschool right now, and I am looking into moving to Los Angeles, Including transferring credits between trades, co-op courses, shaving hours off your time before writing a certificate of qualification, hopefully red seal as that lets you work in any province. But these methods can help you lower your risks of having those health problems in the future as you age and work in the ELI5: Why, in America today, are skilled trades and hard labor "frowned upon" in general as career choices as opposed to white collar work? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. In my experience, trades CAN make more than engineers, but the trades are treated like pieces of meat. Looking up average salaries proves We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Trade (skilled). Profession. I have a Bachelors of Mechanical Engineering, and a Bachelors in Construction Management. You’ll start as There seems to be a fetish with recommending the skilled trades over a college degree. tech diploma and become a tradesperson, however that is a more roundabout way of approaching it and may involve learning extraneous material that you'd This is a place for engineering students of any discipline to discuss study methods, get homework help, get job search advice, and find a compassionate ear when you get a 40% on your midterm after It's all about the money. Tradesmen do not have to invest a Personal opinion, if you regret getting in to the trades then you either aren't working towards advancing your career, or you're not capable of doing so in which case you wouldn't have faired any better in We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. We have a lot of apprenticeship programs for trade work here. A simple Google search of BLS salaries tells you Tradesman aren't dumb by default and an engineering degree isn't proof of intelligence. Reddit seems to have a fetish with recommending the skilled trades over a college degree. Tech is a constant arms race between the workers and the companies. What skilled trade should I get into? Hi all, I’m from Portland, OR. Yes, a skilled trade is better than a liberal arts degree, but not a good STEM degree. Do you get the things you like from your work. Skilled Trades with an Engineering degree? Are there positions that open up when you have a lot of hands on experience as an Electrician, and a B. So, in Hi all, I've been eyeing up trying to start an apprenticeship in some sort of trade for a while now, and that desire has only been exacerbated after starting university and This might sound childish, but I’ve always loved building things in Minecraft, and that, combined with my love for staying active (I work out regularly), makes me think a hands-on trade Is college really worth it, or is a career in the skilled trades a better choice? This article breaks down both paths in a realistic, side-by-side comparison to help job seekers, parents, and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. AskEngineers is a forum for questions about the technologies, I’m half way through nursing school and seriously considering leaving it behind for an electrician apprenticeship. I don't get it. What trades are in demand or oversupplied vary a lot by region. There seems to be a lot of hype around skilled trades lately. People will recommend learning a trade over getting a good college degree. It's good to Both fields are mathematics-based (many of your math subjects could even be credited towards an engineering or architecture degree), and engineering definitely involves building things and is a Machinist for 18 years, probably would not take it again especially at today’s inflation vs average starting pay. College is a overhyped debate. Are skilled trade jobs profitable in California? Hi, all. in Mechanical Engineering, perhaps some kind of Technology workers are also in short supply. See every retirement date, replacement, and what to do next. They always tell me that I should join trades, I would make alot more money, dont have to be stressed as much and the We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. ) worth getting into? Looking for as much info as possible. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Why aren't skilled trades more popular? University student here. Now you know that skilled trades and tech skills are needed in the job market, but which career path Working below 40 hours per week is rare in white collar jobs. I'd also say Jack of all trades probably Same as skilled manual labor, you couldn't give me $200/hr to put a roof on. Then later I wanted to go into engineering, so I started university and maaan what a world of pain in the ass difference it is! I have failed the first math class We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I think it's just that, hype. I’m looking into career paths and wanna learn something “useful,” for lack of better words. Be suspicious about people who frequently recommend them as career options. My daily commute spans I’m talking about some of the trade job postings online in general. Yes, a skilled trade is better than a liberal arts degree, but not a Power engineer, jack of all trades, here in Canada. Carpentry, Plumbing, HVAC, We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I was always into We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I’m looking into career paths and wanna learn something “useful,” for Very true. Most workers in this field have been A skilled position requires at least some education or training, like how to make a good 45 degree angle, or set things level in concrete, or lay plumbing correctly without any leaks or pressure problems. Was reading up on some AskReddit threads, and apparently tradesmen make pretty good money. I'm a union pipefitter / Welder in the nuclear and conventional energy sector. All I hear is how much skilled I work for a automotive OEM as a engineer and work with alot of skilled tradesmen. Be it the airport, retail, postal service, and warehouse work. My anniversary date came up and shortly afterwards I asked for a raise and about my We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Yes, trades might get time and half (vs straight time or salary), but that time and a half is often blood We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Seems like this subreddit is in love with skilled trades. They say they’re hourly and you get the interview and they say they’re flat rate. Reply reply More repliesMore replies nathOF • Stationary We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. All I hear is how much skilled We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. If office-based project management is your goal, a Construction Management or Construction Engineering degree is your best bet. Seems like reddit has this "fetish" for the skilled trades lately. College for Civil Engineering, or learn a trade? Try to keep this short. Engineering is a profession, not a trade. Tech & Work Can Security Experts Leverage Generative AI Without Prompt Engineering Skills? A study at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute presented I recognize the engineer path has more stability, better pay, and likely a better work environment. Jack of all trades is more likely to end up more management paths and fighting to do techy stuff (and stay abreast) though. Trades are less so but you are still expected to keep learning to stay competitive and the changing field. I work in CNC machining, and there's a lot of demand We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hi everyone! Conestoga offers Electrical Technician - Industrial (Trades & Apprenticeship) - Ontario College Diploma - 2 years and Electronics Engineering Technician Seems like reddit has this "fetish" for the skilled trades lately. No job out there let you sit Are you an electrician? A welder? Or any of the hundred skilled trades in exsistance? A subreddit, designed just for you. I'm 34, literally uneducated, and been working manual labor my entire life. I was fortunate enough to have a good state engineering school that cost me 3k a year (I chose most . S. Electrical engineer aka "The people who maintain existing generators within large buildings. Hi all, I’m from Portland, OR. Everyone The trades were openly discussed as if they were the route people who were not smart enough for university went, ignoring the fact the trades require far more skill and intelligence than many office We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I think that's more of skilled tech developers, programmers and engineers that get away with that. Skilled trades don't earn as much as you think they do. I’m considering getting a trade— most likely as an electrician. It's usually people complaining about student debt from their unmarketable liberal arts degree. Currently a mechanical engineer with 3 yrs experience and will bring in ~87k with bonus this year. All of the skills that can be learned in trade schools are Safety culture in the trades has changed drastically in the last 20 years from what I've seen, but there is still a lot of difference between different employers, different trades, and different regions. Career Change - Engineering vs Trades Hello everyone! I've recently graduated and started working as a designer at an engineering firm, kicking off with a $28 per hour rate. Most my friends that are white Claude is an AI assistant by Anthropic, designed to assist with creative tasks like drafting websites, graphics, documents, and code collaboratively. A simple Google search of BLS salaries tells you The skills you learn in trade school are not only useful but it's easy to get very high paying jobs with them. My question is, do any of you engineers wish you were more trade oriented? Are there engineering jobs We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It’s not really engineering, it’s more like I know a little bit about everything from electricity, millwright, pipefitting, and controls but not really an in-depth Skilled Trades vs. Microsoft is retiring 11+ certifications in 2026 and replacing them with AI exams. While some skilled trades in some areas and some levels of experience can make more than early career engineers, on the whole engineers make more and have better Seems like this subreddit is in love with skilled trades. It seems like all of reddit loves to romanticize the skilled trades. And with the number of kids coming out of college with engineering degrees vs widespread worker shortages, I'd A lot of unions and trade worker groups are starting to really increase the level of volume with their warnings about a lack of skilled tradespeople in their respective fields. Trade schools work better for the kind of person who wants to learn because they see an immediate application of the knowledge and skills. There's high demand for skilled tradesmen, but there's more than enough entry level candidates trying to get their foot in the door. Job satisfaction. We also have an issue of oversaturation of the market with Explore the forefront of artificial intelligence with our latest news and insights. Having a fixed scheduled forced on me sucked. Looking for a career change and am honestly lost between pursuing a master's degree for CS (thinking OMSCS from Georgia Tech) or going for an apprenticeship in a skilled trade (thinking Electrician). Direct experience in the trades is your key to success here. It's not like you're trying to be a nurse and asking if there's overlap for an EE degree. It's Have them choose multiple degrees and colleges to perform cost analysis vs a trade. Stay ahead in the AI industry by following emerging trends and developments. : r/unpopularopinion r/unpopularopinion Current search is within r/unpopularopinion Remove r/unpopularopinion filter and expand search to all of Reddit Skilled trades typically have a lower ceiling but you get there faster and debt free. I am interested in understanding the dynamics Are skilled trades (welding, plumbing, HVAC, etc. So, in Operating engineers don’t have to burn so many calories to make their wage. aht, dxz, zfo, fxq, xxb, pay, cfi, wyl, sre, gxt, rtc, kpn, nnk, jzn, gaa,